Friday, July 13, 2012

The truth about the healthcare debate



1 John 3:17-18
If anyone has material possessions and sees his brother in need but has no pity on him, how can the love of God be in him? Dear children, let us not love with words or tongue but with actions and in truth.

As recently as 150 years ago, a doctor in our civilization was little more than a charlatan.  Armed with splints and bone saws, all they could really do was set broken bones, do the occasional amputation, and kill pain with a few potions of questionable efficacy and safety.  Between the Civil War and World War one that slowly changed, and by the twentieth century all doctors were certified, trained men of great learning and were usually quite well paid. 

As that century progressed they gained more knowledge, became specialized, and could use more and more expensive tests and equipment to improve health and save lives.  As the costs for catastrophic care and even general care began to rise, people began to protect themselves en masse from catastrophic health burdens by grouping together in health plans.  Hospital and medical expense policies were introduced during the first half of the 20th century. During the 1920s, individual hospitals began offering services to individuals on a pre-paid basis, eventually leading to the development of Blue Cross organizations.  The predecessors of today's Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) originated beginning in 1929, through the 1930s and on during World War II.  These were by and large always employer paid group plans.  This system continued to work well into the 1980’s.  Costs for these plans were low enough that employers could justify paying for them as an expense required to attract and keep quality employees.

But in the 1980’s the costs began a dramatic rise.  The amount these insurers were charging companies began to be far more than they could justify.  Plans began to cover less and cost more.  Employers no longer found it justifiable to provide comprehensive health insurance to their employees.  Millions of Americans became uninsured or under insured.

What is wrong today is that so many people in the United States do not have health care coverage.  We see evidence of this almost every day.  How many times have you walked into a convenience store and seen a flyer pleading for people to attend a chicken mull or barbecue plate dinner as a means to help finance someone’s, often a child’s, health care costs.  Obviously something is wrong when we have to rely on the donated nickels and dimes of strangers to cover serious health care costs for our friends, our family, and our neighbors.  These people are dying if their health care costs are not covered.  Radiation therapy for cancer and medications to combat the rejection of a transplanted kidney are expensive.

Currently there are nearly 50 million uninsured Americans. These uninsured are not just the healthy young or the poor, but includes working people who either have no access to employer-based health insurance or who cannot afford to pay the premiums; small business persons who don’t qualify for group discounts or other affordable health insurance; and people of all ages with serious health conditions who insurers do not want as customers either at all or only at mind-boggling rates. All of these people will now have access to affordable health insurance.

            Under “Obamacare,” beginning in 2014, people earning less than 133% of the poverty level, $14,856 for an individual or $30,657 for a family of four, will be eligible for Medicaid funded, initially 100% by the federal government and then 90% federally funded. People earning up to 400% of the poverty rate will be eligible for federal subsidies to purchase health insurance if affordable job-based insurance is unavailable. These provisions will stabilize family economics and prevent the often catastrophic effects of unexpected medical bills, which expenses, in 2009, resulted in 900,000 Americans filing bankruptcy.

            While there are penalties if a person despite the above subsidies still chooses not to purchase health insurance, there are exceptions, based on income and cost of insurance. This penalty does not apply until 2014 and will initially be very small, $95 and then increase to $325 in 2015 and $695 in 2016 and will be applied against tax refunds; however, the IRS can neither jail nor seize an individual’s property to collect this penalty.  Thus, there will be no “prosecution” as opponents of the law allege.

            Small employers (25 or fewer employees) who pay at least 50% of their employees’ health insurance premiums, have benefitted from a tax credit since 2010 of up to 35% of the amount paid for employee health insurance.  Employers of more than 50 people will be penalized if by 2014 they don’t provide health insurance; however, the Act provides for the health insurance exchanges which make employers’ group insurance more affordable. These provisions have already and will continue to help new businesses, entrepreneurs and existing small businesses afford to hire new employees and grow their businesses.

            Young people get sick, suffer traumatic accidents, and have babies—all of which require costly health care.  Under the Affordable Care Act children up to age 26 are allowed to remain on their parents’ health insurance, already resulting in millions of previously uninsured youths having insurance. 

By 2014, insurance companies will be required to price and sell policies to everyone regardless of health status and high risk pools have already been established for persons with pre-existing conditions. Finally, many of us will be receiving a refund from our insurance companies next month due to new requirements that 80% of our insurance premiums go to paying claims.
 
            As President Obama has stated, this law is not perfect, but it is a major step forward.  Improvements absolutely can be made, and Congress should do whatever makes sense for the common good. However, the outcry by some to simply reverse Obamacare is non-productive and will do nothing to address the health insurance crisis that Obamacare is designed to address. 

No comments:

Post a Comment